Skip to main content
John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant hero
John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant Logo

John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant

Your Order
No address
Your cart is emptyYour cart is empty

John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant

Welcome to John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant - the right place for a delicious pizza in Middletown, NY! We're a local pizzeria where the food is fresh, the service friendly, and all the customers - satisfied. With that in mind, we joyfully invite you to join us for a hot slice, here in Orange County. Our menu features a number of mouthwatering pies. For a start, you can try our cheese pizza or even create yours and pick all the toppings you like. But we also have other options such as our Pepperoni, Margherita, Buffalo Chicken, and White pie, to name a few. Or you can even go for our great-tasting Sicilian and Gramma pizza. In addition, we offer tasty salads, appetizers, calzones, wraps, entrees, desserts, and others. Plus, we cannot forget about our youngest customers, so we provide an awesome kid's menu as well. It would be our pleasure to have you as one of our customers, so join us for lunch or dinner at our restaurant. Or you could also order us for takeout or delivery on Slice.

Get Directions

order ahead